We were having coffee today at 12 pm(perfectly normal in this place) after class and were having one more of those keeping-in-touch-with-reality conversations. After drinking my coffee, I crushed the cup and casually threw it on the ground. I looked up to see the “ugghhh” look on 3 out 5 faces around me. A fourth one decided I didn’t even deserve a dirty look. For a second, I felt a pang of embarrassment. Embarrassment, mind you, not guilt. Preethi, one of the faces that was kind of enough not to give a dirty look or turn away, bends down, picks up the cup I threw and walks to the nearest dustbin and chucks it in. Two more faces decide to turn away. By this time, the first face who had initiated the turning away process had finished her Appy drink contained a plastic bottle. And my initial feeling of embarrassment turned to a toned down version of amusement. Meanwhile, Preethi comes back, sits down, gives me a smile and starts eating something out of a non-degradable plastic bag. My amusement turned to laughter. This is where I think the environmentalists have got it all wrong. Maybe even fundamentally.
Keeping your campus clean as opposed to saving the planet. If Reshmi or Veena(two of the five faces) had told me that I was a disgusting animal who couldn’t keep my surroundings clean, I d have agreed with them. One hundred percent. I clean my surroundings once in a while, but I ve never bothered to(actually unable to) keep them clean. Maybe the embarrassment from such a statement among a group of friends might have even prompted me to pick the cup up myself. But instead there was an inclination towards this idea of I m not doing anything to save the planet. In fact, I was almost condemned with the act of quickening the execution of Mother Earth.
I don’t know.
The field of vision for the environmentalist trying to save the earth stops with the nearest dustbin. Of course, there is this argument of do-your-bit. But still, for an issue allegedly as serious as the destruction/execution/decay of the Earth, don’t you think it deserves more than just no plastics in a 2 metres radius. Don’t look at me. I don’t believe the Earth is dying. Call me ignorant. Shove all the scientific data into my face. Make me sit next to Al Gore for the next 2 days. Let’s say I still stand strong or rather stubborn on my belief that the Earth is not affected by plastics. But you on the other hand believe that the Earth is dying. Let me re iterate. The Earth, the planet on which you live, the place that provides you food and water and shelter, the place where you found your true love and bought your first pair of branded jeans(in a plastic bag, but that doesn’t matter) and the place that accommodates at least a hundred people you know and care about is actually DYING. You are telling me in some years, the Earth will actually cease to exist and with the Earth so will we. You know all this. And yet, for something as serious as this, you actually make yourself believe that the best you can do is pick up a plastic cup and throw it into the nearest dustbin. Is the contention that arises with I’m-doing-my-part argument of any perceivable significance for an issue that you deem as serious as this?
I don’t think so.
Like I said, I feel there is something fundamentally wrong with the way the environmentalists are pushing this matter. So the way I see it, throwing a paper cup on the ground is wrong, but throwing a plastic cover into a dustbin actually gives you a feeling of adding a few extra seconds to the life of Mother Earth? Why don’t you stop using plastic in the first place? Veena asks me what will the packaging industry do then. Well, I appreciate your kind heart, Veena. We need to take a stance here right? Either go with Mother Earth or with the packaging industry. I m sure we can find substitutes for the plastics we use everyday. But it requires time and effort. How many of us are willing to give that? Or a less painful solution. Don’t buy anything that comes packed only in plastic. I’m sure Preethi could do without eating that thing(man, I need to find the name of that). Or if it is an inevitable purchase, then demand for a paper bag. Or take your own bag. Bringing the Shoppers Stop bag down to your room and carefully placing it inside the dustbin, somehow doesn’t t appeal to me as an effective method to save the Earth. How do you know the plastic is safe and secure in the dustbin? In my defense, the paper cup may have even acted as manure for the soil, or it may have even created employment opportunities for another rag picker. Have you ever cared to think about what happens to the plastic bag after you render your services to mitigate the imminent threat it posed??????
Find out in The Life of the Plastic bag..
PS: Ignore the grammar errors before, now and after.
Monday, October 6, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
:) "Pay-per plastic" can be the name of ur campaign against plastic.. well written..keep writing.. am enjoying reading it all..
Nice work..But if u ask me I wud say both throwin d paper cup and plastic bag n d ground is wrong. U happen to justify one. But how did U forget d Forests cleared for makin ur paper cups? d flora and fauna along with those forests?
Ur concrete buildings? Effluents from factories run freely into d water sources in many parts of India. inspite of Pollution control boards..All thanks to Corruption. How many Campaigns can v hold? wer do v start? No to plastic alone is not gonna save mother earth but all d same its a good initiative.
good writing but one sided logic...neither the paper cup nor the plastic bag is good environmentally..and where u throw it after use hardly matters, as in india it hardly goes for recycle anyways..i think these topics of saving earth, social service, corruption, etc make good tea time discussion topics...but when was the last time that any of us stopped and picked up a plastic bag from the road and put it in a bin?or when was it that we shamed a man who spat/smoked/peed in a public place?my friend...blogging will not change the world...we need to go out and do it!!!!!
u r rite priyanka... my point exactly.. blogging wont help.. so wont stopping wit just clearing plastic cups..
in either case, i m not here to save the world.. i m not arrogant enough to think the Earth needs MY help to survive(courtesy: george carlin).. and if u think it needs YOURS, i just want to know why u are not doing anything other than just clearing plastic cups in ur immediate surrounding..
he he.. this seems to be heavily inspired by george carlin... and dude i will go with u on this of one... Well who proposed the concept of "Earth needs to be saved"! Are we arrogant enough to think that we petty humans can save teh planet.. as george carlin says.. the earth doesn't need saving! It has been here for 5 million years and will remain for a still longer time. We do the environmentalist thing to save our own asses! ;) And after all the earth may actually like plastics and created us in the first place so that we can make plastics!
@ashwin
yeah man.. carlin is god..
Post a Comment